$$$$ Clinic Cost Index
Home / Compare settings

Does the setting change the price?

The same procedure category, priced across different kinds of facility. Each figure is the median markup: what hospitals of that type charge relative to what they told Medicare the service costs them. Lower is cheaper. The last column is how much the setting alone moves it.

Procedure categorySmall hospitalMid-size hospitalLarge hospitalHospital in a health systemGovernment or public hospitalSpread
Surgery (operating room)4.3×6.0×6.0×5.6×4.1×1.5×
Post-surgery recovery4.1×5.0×4.8×4.9×3.8×1.3×
Childbirth and delivery2.0×2.4×2.9×2.4×2.1×1.5×
Anesthesia9.9×12.6×12.9×13.4×8.4×1.6×
X-ray and diagnostic imaging4.7×6.2×6.7×6.0×4.6×1.4×
CT scan19.0×21.8×24.4×21.6×19.9×1.3×
MRI11.1×13.6×14.0×13.9×11.7×1.3×
Cardiac catheterisation6.7×8.5×9.8×8.7×8.1×1.5×
Lab tests and bloodwork5.1×8.3×9.0×7.3×5.1×1.8×
Respiratory therapy3.4×6.0×6.3×5.3×3.9×1.8×
Physical therapy2.6×3.3×3.4×3.1×2.4×1.4×
Occupational therapy3.0×4.1×4.2×3.6×2.6×1.6×
Speech therapy2.7×4.0×4.0×3.6×2.5×1.6×
EKG and heart monitoring9.9×11.6×12.1×11.9×9.1×1.3×
EEG brain monitoring4.3×4.8×5.8×5.1×4.3×1.4×
Implanted devices2.8×3.2×3.2×3.2×2.6×1.2×
Drugs given at the facility3.5×4.8×4.5×4.2×3.5×1.3×
Dialysis2.8×3.1×3.4×3.2×2.5×1.4×
Outpatient clinic visit2.3×2.5×2.3×2.5×1.8×1.4×
Emergency room visit5.0×7.3×7.0×7.2×4.6×1.6×
Observation stay1.9×2.8×2.8×2.6×1.9×1.4×
Inpatient room and board1.8×2.2×2.3×2.1×1.5×1.5×
Intensive care (ICU)1.8×2.4×2.8×2.4×2.0×1.5×
What this shows. For most categories the small community hospital and the public hospital sit at the cheap end, and the large hospital or health-system member sits at the expensive end. The gap is not small: for laboratory work and emergency visits the setting alone moves the markup by roughly half again. If a procedure can safely be done in more than one setting, that choice is worth real money.
Ambulatory surgery centres are missing from this table, and that matters. Surgery centres do not file Medicare cost reports, so no audited cost-to-charge figure exists for them and we will not invent one. They are listed throughout this directory but deliberately left unrated. The evidence that they are usually the cheaper setting comes from Medicare's own payment rules, which pay a surgery centre less than a hospital outpatient department for the same outpatient procedure. See the roadmap.